Pizza, pasta, fresh grouper and (of course) rum. There is no shortage of stellar Captiva Island restaurants and shops to keep you well fed on your next vacation.
Note: Previously located at The Island Store Captiva prior to its renovation, Molly Malone’s Seafood will remain at the Santiva General Store on Sanibel’s northern point. Be sure to grab your order before crossing Blind Pass.
Last Update: March 2022
Restaurants on Captiva Island
If you’re wondering where to eat, get a cup of coffee or buy a snack, we’ve got you covered. Below is a list of Captiva Island restaurants, coffee shops, bars and markets. This list of restaurants on Captiva Island is organized from the south heading north.
‘TWEEN WATERS ISLAND RESORT & SPA AREA RESTAURANTS
Old Captiva House
15951 Captiva Dr, Captiva Island, FL 33924
OldCaptivaHouse.com
Old Captiva House has recently been restored and features a new menu. This is one of the island’s most popular options for fine dining. Located on the Tween Waters property, Old Captiva House is a convenient option for those staying on or near the resort. Those closer to Andy Rosse Lane or at South Seas will want to drive, unless you want to take a relaxing stroll along the beach on your way back home.
Crow’s Nest Bar & Grille
15951 Captiva Dr, Captiva Island, FL 33924
Crow’s Nest Steakhouse is the modern steakhouse that the island was missing. You’ll want to be sure to make reservations. This is a can’t miss spot.
The Shipyard
15951 Captiva Dr, Captiva Island, FL 33924
Longtime guests will remember this as the old Crow’s Nest. ‘Tween Waters has elevated its dining options with The Shipwayd, its casual eatery open for breakfast and dinner.
Oasis Pool Bar – $
15951 Captiva Dr, Captiva Island, FL 33924
The Oasis serves hot food and cold drinks for lunch, a menu perfect for a day spent poolside. Burgers, sandwiches and wraps, oh my! Plenty of blended drinks to cool you down and quench your thirst while working hard on your tan.
BAYSIDE AREA CAPTIVA ISLAND RESTAURANTS
The Green Flash – $$$$
15183 Captiva Dr, Captiva Island, FL 33924
GreenFlashCaptiva.com
Named for the optical illusion seen at sunset, The Green Flash is a fine dining restaurant that overlooks Pine Island Sound. Located between Andy Rosse Lane and Tween Waters Inn on the bay side of the island, the Green Flash features a European-centric menu that expertly incorporates some of Florida’s prime seafood choices. Don’t miss their Green Flash drink, a unique take on a pina colada.
ANDY ROSSE LANE AREA CAPTIVA ISLAND RESTAURANTS
The Mucky Duck – $$$ – Currently Closed
11546 Andy Rosse Lane, Captiva Island, FL 33924
MuckyDuck.com
The Mucky Duck Captiva is the island’s watering hole. Situated on the beach, the Mucky Duck is a British Pub-inspired restaurant where vacationers flock for sunset. Appetizers and drinks are available on the beach-facing patio, with the full menu available for indoor dining. Arrive early if you’re hoping for dinner at a window table; giving you a front row seat for sunset. It is the best place to watch sunset on Captiva Island!
Captiva Island Pizza – $
11511 Andy Rosse lane, Captiva Island FL 33924
CaptivaIslandPizza.com/
This is one of our family’s go-to stops each trip. Captiva Island Pizza offers New York style pies large enough to feed a family of four. There are a few tables inside the restaurant, but it’s primarily a take-out pizzeria. Free delivery is available Fridays and Saturdays. If you go, get the Cannonball Pizza. Bon Appetit!
Keylime Bistro $$ – Currently Closed
11508 Andy Rosse Lane, Captiva Island, FL 33924
Website
Yes, they have key lime pie. In fact, the Keylime Bistro Key Lime Pie is the best version you can get on Captiva. Don’t miss your chance to taste the famous pie highlighted in Bon Appetit magazine. The Keylime Bistro’s menu also features an eclectic choice of entrees and drinks. While there isn’t a strong nightlife on Captiva Island, the patio at the Keylime Bistro is where people gather for free music and light dancing at night.
Sunshine Seafood Cafe and Wine Bar – $$$$
11508 Andy Rosse Lane, Captiva Island, FL 33924
Website
For wine lovers on Captiva, this is your place. Sunshine Seafood Cafe is fine dining in a more casual atmosphere. Bonus for families; kids are welcome. Options include fillet mignon, rack of lamb and paella. Get the crab cakes.
RC Otter’s Island Eats – $$
11506 Andy Rosse Lane, Captiva Island, FL 33924
Website
RC Otters is open breakfast through dinner and has a wonderful kids menu for $5.99. This is a great place if you’re looking for a filling meal at a lower price range.
Latte Da – $
11508 Andy Rosse Lane, Captiva Island, FL 33924
Website
Latte Da Captiva is an ice cream and coffee shop. Unless you’re staying at South Seas, this is the place for your morning caffeine fix as the lines are nowhere near as long as Starbucks down the road. Open 8 a.m. – 9 p.m. daily.
The Bubble Room – $$$
15001 Captiva Dr, Captiva, FL 33924
BubbleRoomRestaurant.com
For those who’ve been coming to Captiva for decades, The Bubble Room is the often the first restaurant that comes to mind. Located at the corner of Andy Rosse Lane and Captiva Dr, it’s hard to miss. Even if you don’t eat here, be sure to grab a slice of cake to-go at their new shop next door.
Boops by the Bubble Room – $
15001 Captiva Dr, Captiva, FL 33924
BubbleRoomRestaurant.com
The Bubble Room has leaned into its greatest asset with the addition of Boops By The Bubble Room. Located in the Bubble Room parking lot across the street from their gift shop, this desert bar/ice cream parlor/soda fountain/coffee bar is the island’s newest eatery. The desserts here are amazing, and built to share. Even if you don’t eat here, be sure to grab a slice of cake to-go.
Cantina Captiva
14970 Captiva Dr, Captiva, FL 33924
Website
The furthest north of the restaurants in the village area, Captiva Cantina is the island’s Mexican/Southwestern establishment. With its pitchers of beer, sangria and margaritas, the Cantina is great for groups or for catching up with old friends. Stop by for meal and place a dollar on the wall or ceiling.
SOUTH SEAS RESORT – PUBLIC RESTAURANTS AND SHOPS
Captiva Provision Company – $
5400 Plantation Rd, Captiva, FL 33924
Website
Captiva Provision Company is a liquor store, sandwich shop, and full-service market. Operated by South Seas Island Resort, this market is off campus and open to the public. Grab-and-go options include sandwiches and several flavors of rotisserie chicken. Its alcohol and market offerings will generally save you from making a Sanibel run.
Starbucks – $
5400 Plantation Rd, Captiva, FL 33924
Starbucks.com
No explanation needed here. As one of two island coffee shops, and the one with national recognition, it can get busy. One note to first-timers: the line is out the door most mornings, don’t count on making a coffee run on Saturday mornings if you have an earlier flight.
Bonus: Farmers’ Market
5400 Plantation Rd, Captiva, FL 33924
Website
Every Tuesday, November – April, South Seas Island Resort hosts the Captiva Island Farmers Market from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. near the main entrance. More than 30 vendors offer food and gifts. 2019-2020 offerings included. Open to the public.
SOUTH SEAS – NON-PUBLIC RESTAURANTS AND SHOPS
Located miles from the main gate of South Seas, these restaurants are open only to those with access to the resort.
Harborside Bar and Grill – Opening Soon
South Seas Marina
Website
Open for breakfast and dinner, Harbourside overlooks the South Seas marina. Harbourside is the resorts fine dining restaurant. Kids menu available.
Redfish Grill
South Seas Pool Area
Website
With the Harbourview closed for lunch, this is South Sea’s table service lunch option. The Pointe is open 11 a.m. until sunset.
Tarpon Bar
South Seas Pool Area
Website
If your idea of vacation is laying by the pool, drink in hand, then the Crooked Snook Tiki Bar is where you’ll spend your days. Both food and drink are available, service is poolside. The view here is one of the best on the island.
Scoops and Slices
South Seas Pool Area
Website
Scoops and Slices is a ice cream parlor, pizza joint and candy store. Stop in for a scoop or a slice.
Shell City burders
Sunset Beach – South Seas
Website
Shell City Burgers is South Sea’s beach-side food truck – it’s also where vacation goers gather at sunset.
Still Have Questions?
